1881 Second Empire – Henry, IL – $72,900

For Sale Foreclosure
Added to OHD on 3/13/18 - Last OHD Update: 3/14/18 - 36 Comments
506 Carroll St, Henry, IL 61537

Maps: Street, Aerial











In 1881 this French 2nd Empire style home with mansard roof, fully bracketed and articulated, with a plain Italianate base and Gothic Revival interior was started. The home's frame was constructed with pegs (no nails at all!) by the original owner (Frederick Potter I, a retired shipbuilder) who also created the cornices, tower, doors and sash. He designed the woodwork and each piece was numbered, as was each piece of lumber in the 16 room house. From the two etched marble fireplaces to the grand dining room with mahogany built ins to the original Queen Ann glass window in the 50' tall tower, this home is incredible. In 1964 after 5 generations of the original Potter family living in the home, it was sold outside the family and has been occupied almost continuously since. The home has been registered with the Central Illinois Landmark Foundation and wears a plaque to show it. The huge lot includes a gorgeous carriage house and a greenhouse that was imported from Europe.
Contact Details
Janelle McCarter, Landmark Realty
(815) 875-1221
Links & Additional Info
OHD does not represent this home. Property details must be independently verified.

36 Comments on 1881 Second Empire – Henry, IL – $72,900

  1. When I saw the exterior, I said to myself “be still my heart”! Love at 1st sight, too bad I’m older and the sq ft is too much for me to live in or want to deal with….

  2. I’ve seen this before, a grand old home. Have wondered about the faint etchings on the fireplace.

    • The mantel is slate, with incised decoration and a faux marbleized finish, a pretty one though relatively common.

      It’s crazy to be able to buy an antique house of this quality at the price, though the foreclosure and a slow local economy accounts for it. Taxes aren’t bad for Illinois at about $3000. A few of us should get together and make it the OHD Old Folks Home.

      • I’m in! I get my first social security check in May, I’m an official member of the old people club 🙂

      • I have often thought that a nonprofit, co-operative effort in that regard would be a VERY wise idea for those of moderate, stable means who do not have large supportive families, and who do not wish to end up in institutionalized elder warehousing, to invest in. How that would happen, or if current examples exist, I am unaware. Though this house is great, I’d much rather fade away in that great house down in MS where it’s nice and warm, and taxes and costs overall are relatively inexpensive. + the chair is already there ready to schlep my future old azz up and down the stairs in vintage style! Heheheh 😉

        • The millennial generation calls it co-living and are really into it. They like the sense of community and it’s much cheaper than having a home solo.

        • I’m a good bit away from retirement, but I have had the same thought myself. I don’t know if it is a “thing,” as they say, but it would be a way to not worry about the future and have something to look forward to.

        • I don’t think we will ever retire but that is the idea I want for the expansion of Aloha Farm. To create a community that is there to help the chronically ill and with the rescue animals that work with them. I have always loved the idea of community and having others around. One of the things that they find in the places where people live longest is that they have very tight knit communities. I truly want to go to my grave knowing I loved many.

      • I too have thought about repurposing homes in this manner. The only drawback are the stairs. I live in a college town, and investors here are restoring the old homes and turning them into housing for college students. Not idea but better than losing the houses. The exteriors are restored. The public rooms are restored. The bedrooms and bathrooms are updated.

      • I felt the same exact way and moreso as I went through it (by pics;) I am in the same situation as you — just a bit too old for the loving touches it needs and too large.. Oh, well. <3

  3. I wonder if Olson and Johnson get kidded about their name…just kidding. This old place is great. The neighborhood looks peaceful. The crime rate is low according to Realtor.com. I really like this one.

    • Henry is a fine, all-American town. Home to the annual county fair and one of the best 4th of July celebrations I have ever been to.

  4. I’m in. I will bring the gallons of stripper for all that unfortunate paint. Wish there were some photos of the carriage house and the tower.

    • You buy the house…I’ll rent the carriage house from you for life. Oh, I probably don’t have that much longer to live but I can dream…

    • I completely misread part of this comment and am now both ashamed and tickled. Good grief…..

  5. I said it when this was posted in the link exchange and I’ll say it again. That’s a whole lot of magificent house (and carriage house) for a pretty darned good price. Wish I was ready to retire and take on this as a project.

  6. I sure hope that the person/people that buy this keep those fabulous sinks in the bedrooms! I love those and believe that it was an awesome detail that helped people to deal with dad being in the bathroom when you had to brush your teeth and wash up, lol!

    • Some great original details all over this one. The sinks are what caught my eye as well. I would like to get a closer look at what appears to be the carriage house!

  7. Love this beautiful house! Too bad it’s located in Illinois. Too far, but one can dream.

  8. This is the most exciting fixer so far this year IMO. If it’s not EOlson who ends up with it, I sure hope it’s going to be someone with an equal amount of enthusiasm for just how great this place is and could be even more so with not all that much effort really. Not to mention the fact that It’s a SMOKIN good deal at that price; (and likely it will end up in that range). LOCATION, (as always), regarding the relative remoteness of Henry, is going to be the most significant factor in the story of what happens to this GREAT house. Fingers crossed for a OHD happy ending!!! 🙂

  9. My jaw always drops when I see the prices asked for amazing places like this. Here in Belgium, you wouldn’t even get the piece of land for that price, not even if it comes out of a foreclosure. Besides that comment, the house is spectacular, with all these little extra features everywhere, all except the horrible carpet of course.

  10. Kelly went and poured on the “awesome sauce” with this one! In love with it, for sure! I wish my house had a tower that grand!

  11. I’ve always wanted to redo an old grand home. Wish it were further south. Too old for this cold. I always thought I would redo a home and become a foster parent. I grew up in an orphanage and that was always my dream. Just didn’t work out.

  12. Not very often you find one to restore but still can live in as you do it. Also not very often you find one with an intact carriage house! This is a steal of a deal, feel sorry though for the person who had the foreclosure, you could see he/she was starting some restore work.

  13. Henry is between LaSalle and Peoria on the Illinois River at the site of the first lock and dam on that river. A beautiful setting, lots of history, not all that far to either location for work with the charm of small town living. Illinois has a lot of negative Chicago and state government PR out there (with just reasons) but these little towns, along the Mississippi, Illinois and Ohio Rivers are wonderful places to live and even restore old homes. As to this home, I’ve never been one to think “I’ll buy this home and stripe all the wood” – I can either live with the paint or pass on the house. BUT this may be the one exception where I’d strip all the paint off the stairway because it would make a HUGE difference in it’s beauty and match the rest of the downstairs wood. Seems to be the perfect home to restore to awesomeness.

  14. corner sink is cute, build ins r awesome, price unbelievable, would love to see the european greenhouse

  15. mon Dieu! C’est magnifique!!!!!
    Arsenic and old lace, anyone? I couldn’t do this on my own, like so many others.

  16. As others have said, such a lovely home! The only changes I’d make are to the decor so that it isn’t so dark and to strip the paint. (I know some of these houses had painted woodwork originally, but surely not avocado green!) Really, I think I love everything about this house and would seriously consider it – except that I don’t live anywhere near IL and don’t look to move there any time soon. Ah, well; this will be such a delight for the person who does get it!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Think before you type! Pretend the owner, the agent, your mom, your grandmother and the deity of your religion are standing in the room and what you are about to say you are saying to their face. If your comment does not add value to the conversation in a positive manner, it may not appear publicly. Also, read the comment rules & disclaimer before commenting (updated 1/3/18).

All comments are moderated and do not appear public right away. OHD does not represent this home. Price and status must be independently verified. Do not rely on comments about the status or condition of the home, contact the agent and see it in person.