1822 Church in Lisle, NY
6/17/26
7 Comments
Details on OHD may be outdated. Verify using the link references below.
As of 6/17/26, this home was for sale.
As of 6/17/26, this home was for sale.
$120,000
2098 River St, Lisle, NY 13797
Built in 1822 and converted to a private residence in the late 1970s, this historic property showcases exceptional original craftsmanship. Set directly on the Tioughnioga River, it features 40-ft ceilings, extensive original stained glass, and a dramatic upper-level primary suite with balcony views over the main hall. Constructed with 18" beams, floor-to-ceiling pillars, and a preserved 900 lb original brass bell, the home retains exceptional historic character. A 1914 stained glass triptych serves as a centerpiece. Recent upgrades include a 2018 Amish-installed metal roof, updated PEX plumbing, modern electric, and efficient ductless Rinnai propane heating plus a refurbished 90,000 BTU coal stove. Enjoy spacious side yards, river access for kayaking toward Whitney Point Reservoir, and proximity to a village park with seasonal pool. Not located in a flood risk zone due to levee protection. Ideal as a primary residence, retreat, or potential Airbnb near Ithaca (27 miles west).
2 Bed ∙ 1 Bath ∙ 3,368 Sq Ft ∙ 0.72 Ac.
Listed With
Steven Mandeville
EXIT Realty Homeward Bound
607-768-3737
Reference Links
State: New York | Region: Northeast (Middle Atlantic) | Associated Styles or Type: Church | Period & Associated Styles: Romantic Era | Misc: Commercial/Business Use, Offbeat & Unique |


































