A collection of historic homes for those who dream...

1869 Church in Middleport, NY

Price changes, listing status and other details may not be current.
Property was for sale as of (1/2/26).
Check the links below for current information.
$285,000

Please use the links below to see current listing information.

56 Main St, Middleport, NY 14105

Let your ideas run wild as you step into history with this extraordinary opportunity to create a truly one-of-a-kind single-family residence. Formerly an iconic Baptist Church, this architectural gem is rich in character and brimming with potential for a dramatic and inspiring home transformation. At the heart of the building is a stunning original 1906 Barkhoff Church Organ Co. (Ohio) pipe organ, impeccably preserved and fully operational—a rare and remarkable feature. The property’s historical significance may qualify it for state and federal historic tax credits, offering valuable incentives for restoration and adaptive reuse. Recent updates include a brand-new metal roof, updated electrical and plumbing systems, and meticulously replicated 1869 front entry doors, all preserving the building’s timeless craftsmanship while ensuring modern reliability. This is a rare opportunity to reimagine a historic landmark as a remarkable private residence, blending architectural heritage with modern living while shaping its next chapter.
4,660 Sq Ft · 0.41 Ac.
Listed With
State: | Region: | Associated Styles or Type: | Period & Associated Styles: , | Misc: , , |
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Civility is expected. This site is devoted to historic architecture and the stories it carries—please keep discussions within those walls. Comments are overseen by both readers and automated moderation. Should you encounter an unsuitable remark, kindly click the red flag in the upper right corner of the comment.

Political commentary of any kind is strictly forbidden.

By commenting, you affirm that you have read—and shall abide by—the comment policy.
[Click here to review the full comment policy.] Updated 4/20/22.

Old House Dreams does not represent this property. All listing details should be independently verified.